Find Quality Web Information

Planning Your Search Strategy     |     Searching the Web      |        Evaluating Web Information

Planning Your Search Strategy

A well-planned search strategy greatly improves the chances of finding the information you need.

1. Define the topic in your own words. It can be helpful to state the topic in the form of a question, e.g., what are the effects of television violence on children?

2. Identify the main concepts and keywords. For the topic, what are the effects of television violence on children?, the main concepts would be: television, violence, children.

3. Refine your search terms. 

Consider:

  • synonyms/different forms of keywords, e.g., tv in addition to television
  • alternative spellings. Consider British vs. American spellings, e.g., labour/labor, and even mis-spellings, e.g., geneology vs. genealogy
  • truncation and wildcards, e.g., child* will retrieve child, children; wom*n will retrieve woman, women

4. Combine the terms

AND (+)   retrieves records with both terms, e.g., television AND violence

OR   retrieves records with either term, e.g., television OR tv

NOT (-)   retrieves records with the first term but not the second, e.g., child* NOT adolescent*

NEAR   retrieves records with terms within a certain number of words of each other, e.g., television NEAR violence

Also Consider:

  • phrase searching--the use of quotation marks to ensure that words appear immediately next to each other, e.g.,"television violence"
  • nesting--the use of round brackets to specify the order in which searching should be done, e.g., ("television violence " OR "tv violence") AND child*
  • field searching. Depending on the search engine, you may be able to search by one or more fields (specific portions of a webpage), such as title, URL, etc.

5. Construct the search strategy

For: what are the effects of television violence on children?
One strategy could be: (television OR tv) AND violence AND child*

Try this Search Strategy Tutorial:

Searching 101 (Ohio State University) 
http://liblearn.osu.edu/tutor/les4/
 

 Searching the Web

There are essentially three types of tools to use when searching the Web, i.e., subject directories, search engines, and meta-search tools.

Subject directories are lists of selected Web resources arranged by topic in a hierarchical way. These small databases are compiled by human beings, so are comparatively small, and can sometimes get out of date quickly. Search results are usually highly relevant, however.

Use subject directories when looking for:

  • general information on a subject
  • a popular topic
  • a broad topic
  • a specialized database
  • a metapage (a website created by a subject expert or other interested party who collects URLs and makes them available from one site)

Selected Subject Directories

Search Engines are word-by-word indexes of web resources gathered by a computer program. These databases are substantially larger and more current than subject directories. Finding relevant documents can be more difficult, however. Use search engines when looking for specific information, or information on a current topic.

Selected Search Engines

Meta-Search Tools allow you to search several tools at one time. They speed up the search process and are useful for searches with unique terms. However, they lack access to all the advanced search features the individual tools provide and might present only the first few results from each tool.

Selected Meta-Search Tools

Web Searching Tips

  • Use more than one search tool
  • Look for Help information from each tool's website, or look for a tip sheet or chart showing the details of the various tools
  • Don't bog down in any search strategy which doesn't work
  • Remember: the information you’re seeking may not be available for free on the Web

Try  this Web Searching Tutorial:

Bare Bones 101 (University of South Carolina)
A basic tutorial on searching the Web.
http://www.sc.edu/beaufort/library/pages/bones/bones.shtml

Looking for More Information on Searching the Web?

The Extreme Searcher's Internet Handbook  : A Guide for the Serious Searcher / Randolph Hock
E-book

Finding Information on the Internet (University of California, Berkeley)
http://www.lib.berkeley.edu/TeachingLib/Guides/Internet/FindInfo.html

Google Search Secrets / Michael P. Sauers and Christa Burns
E-book

An Introduction to Search Engines and Web Navigation / Mark Levene
E-book

Search Tools Chart (InfoPeople)
https://infopeople.org/content/best-search-tools-chart

Evaluating Web Information

The quality of information found on the World Wide Web varies greatly. Therefore, it is extremely important to critically evaluate information you find on the Web. Consider the following criteria:

  • Accuracy
  • Authority
  • Objectivity
  • Currency
  • Coverage
  • Site design

Accuracy

  • Is the information reliable and error-free?
  • Is there a bibliography? If so, consider the quality of sources cited.
  • Is the information fact or opinion?
  • Are there grammatical or spelling errors?

Authority

  • Is the page signed?
  • Is the author qualified? What experience or formal credentials does the person have? Has the author written anything else on this topic?
  • Can the author be contacted by phone and mail, as well as by email?
  • Who is the sponsor/publisher? Reputable?

Objectivity

  • Does the information show a minimum of bias?
  • What is the purpose of the webpage?
  • Is there any advertising on the page? If so, is it separate from the informational content?

Currency

  • When was the information originally presented?
  • How often is it updated?
  • How current are the links? Have some expired or moved?

Coverage

  • What topics are covered?
  • What does this page offer that is not found elsewhere?
  • How in-depth is the material?

Site Design

  • Is the website well organized? Is it easy to navigate within the site?
  • Is special software required to access all the features of the site?
  • Is the colour scheme appealing?
  • Do graphics enhance the content, rather than distract?

Try this Web Evaluation Tutorial:

Evaluating Web Sites (Ohio State University) 
Brief tutorial introducing the techniques for judging the value of websites for research purposes.
http://liblearn.osu.edu/tutor/les1/

Looking for More Information on Web Evaluation?

Evaluating Information Found on the Internet (Elizabeth E. Kirk, Johns Hopkins University)
http://guides.library.jhu.edu/evaluate

Evaluating Internet Research Sources (Robert Harris)
http://www.virtualsalt.com/evalu8it.htm
 

Created by: Betty Jeffery, B.A., M.L.S.
Former Instruction & Education Services Librarian
Date Created: 23-May-2000
Date Revised: 17-July-2017